Saturday, November 21, 2026

Favourite Poems: LInes on a Young Lady's Photograph Album by Philip Larkin

My Big Four of poets are W.B. Yeats, Philip Larkin, Lord Alfred Tennyson, and Louis MacNeice. Each of them wrote, not just a handful of good poems, but very many of them. There simply seems to be more to them than other poets. When I write something like this, I realize how ludicrous it sounds. Surely there is more to Milton or Chaucer than MacNeice? Yes, probably, but they don't seem to relate to my life as much. Perhaps Chaucer addressed the human condition in a more profound and wide-reaching way than Louis MacNeice; nevertheless MacNeice wrote about Dublin and Sunday mornings and pop culture in a way that Chaucer couldn't have.

"Flavour" is also relevant. Even though these four poets ranged far and wide in their exploration of life, their basic sensibility is one that appeals to me and in which I feel at home. Larkin's melancholy (and Englishness); MacNeice's relish for the passing moment, while constantly seeking for something more; Yeats's sense of the heroic; Tennyson's idealism constantly struggling with pessimism. And, on a more "granular" level (as we say these days), these are simply the four poets who, more than any others, consistently came up with phrases, lines, and turns of phrase that appeal to me. Without great craftsmanship, nobody (except modern poetry critics) would care about a poet's thoughts and ideas-- just like nobody would care about Paul McCartney's musings on heartbreak if he hadn't written the meoldy to "Yesterday".

(What about Shakespeare? I don't really think of him as poet, though I agree this is quite arbitrary.)

Anyway, all that is a preamble that got away from me. The poem I wanted to feature today is "Lines on a Young Lady's Photograph Album" by Philip Larkin.

I consider this poem the foremost example of a whole sub-genre of poetry, what I might call "contemplating photographs" poetry. Photographs are endlessly evocative, and endlessly stimulating of the poetic mood.

But even beyond that distinct subgenre (which has its own unique virtues), I think this poem is an example of a broader subgenre of poetry-- poems about a particular person (usually unnamed) in a particular situation, contemplating it. The person is usually alone and little or nothing actually happens in the poem, other than the person's thoughts. This is the pattern of many of Larkin's poems, for instance "Church Going", "The Whitsun Weddings", "Aubade", "Sad Steps", and many others.

(I even invented a fake anthology of such poems, which I titled Thinking Alone: Poems of Solitary Reflection, and mock-announced in this blog post. To my surprise, a couple of commenters took it seriously. I'm never trying to fool people with such posts-- it's just a bit of fun, a bit of wishful thinking.)


"Lines on a Young Lady's Photograph Album" has had a huge influence on me personally, as a poet-- for whatever that's worth. I've written oodles of poems about a solitary, unnamed figure in a particular situation or setting, thinking about it. This is my favourite sort of poem to write. I've also written a few poems about photographs.

What I love about "Lines..." is its gentle melancholy and bittersweetness-- the sort of melancholy that is so gentle, it's really more pleasant than unpleasant.

Here are some of my favourite lines from it:

Too much confectionery, too rich:
I choke on such nutritious images.

And:

A sweet girl-graduate

And: 

This is a real girl in a real place,
In every sense empirically true

And the fantastic, haunting last line:

Smaller and clearer as the years go by.

For all Larkin's well-advertised coarseness and crassness about sex, and about women, he could write brilliantly and touchingly about femininity, in all of its grace and gradations. (As I mentioned in a recent post, I really love the title of his novel A Girl in Winter-- partly for this reason.)

Fittingly for the theme, the poem itself seems like a period piece now. Does anybody keep photograph albums anymore? Does anyone get called a "young lady" these days?

My favourite part of the poem is the meditation on photography:

But o, photography! as no art is,
Faithful and disappointing! that records
Dull days as dull, and hold-it smiles as frauds,
And will not censor blemishes
Like washing-lines, and Hall's-Distemper boards,

But shows a cat as disinclined, and shades
A chin as doubled when it is, what grace
Your candour thus confers upon her face!
How overwhelmingly persuades
That this is a real girl in a real place,

In every sense empirically true!

I could write endlessly about this poem, so I'll stop it there, and just give you the poem itself. (Is it ridiculous to have a lengthy discussion of a poem before presenting the text? Actually, I don't think so. I think it heightens the experience. I often read movie reviews before going to see a film.)

Lines On A Young Lady's Photograph Album

At last you yielded up the album, which
Once open, sent me distracted. All your ages
Matt and glossy on the thick black pages!
Too much confectionery, too rich:
I choke on such nutritious images.

My swivel eye hungers from pose to pose —
In pigtails, clutching a reluctant cat;
Or furred yourself, a sweet girl-graduate;
Or lifting a heavy-headed rose
Beneath a trellis, or in a trilby-hat

(Faintly disturbing, that, in several ways) —
From every side you strike at my control,
Not least through those these disquieting chaps who loll
At ease about your earlier days:
Not quite your class, I'd say, dear, on the whole.

But o, photography! as no art is,
Faithful and disappointing! that records
Dull days as dull, and hold-it smiles as frauds,
And will not censor blemishes
Like washing-lines, and Hall's-Distemper boards,

But shows a cat as disinclined, and shades
A chin as doubled when it is, what grace
Your candour thus confers upon her face!
How overwhelmingly persuades
That this is a real girl in a real place,

In every sense empirically true!
Or is it just the past? Those flowers, that gate,
These misty parks and motors, lacerate
Simply by being you; you
Contract my heart by looking out of date.

Yes, true; but in the end, surely, we cry
Not only at exclusion, but because
It leaves us free to cry. We know what was
Won't call on us to justify
Our grief, however hard we yowl across

The gap from eye to page. So I am left
To mourn (without a chance of consequence)
You, balanced on a bike against a fence;
To wonder if you'd spot the theft
Of this one of you bathing; to condense,

In short, a past that no one now can share,
No matter whose your future; calm and dry,
It holds you like a heaven, and you lie
Unvariably lovely there,
Smaller and clearer as the years go by.

Friday, November 20, 2026

This Is Funny

Unlike Bishop Barron, I'm not particularly a fan of The Chosen, the TV series that has recently dramatized the story of Jesus. I watched a few episodes with great interest but then my interest waned. I think the makers took too many liberties with the Gospel story. That's just my viewpoint.

However, I've watched a particular moment from a discussion between Bishop Barron and Jonathan Roumie (the actor who played Jesus) again and again over the last few years.  They are speaking before a live audience. Bishop Barron gives a potted history of Catholic Christology and Roumie's reaction is (I think) hilarious. Perhaps that doesn't sound like comedy gold to you, and it's quite a long build up (about four minutes). But if you're not in a hurry, it might be worth it.

Click here to go the start of Bishop Barron's mini-lecture.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

A Strange Quirk, Perhaps

I've just been reading a book about the 1916 Rising leader, MIchael Mallin. (One of the lesser-known of the sixteen who were executed.) It includes this sentence: "The most infamous aspect of Mallin's Rising is the decision not to occupy, or attempt to occupy, the Shelbourne Hotel".

The Shelbourne Hotel is a large and historic hotel which overlooks Stephen's Green, the park in Dublin city centre in which Mallin's men set up their garrison. It's a luxury hotel that has hosted various famous people down the years, including John F. Kennedy. Recently there was a ludicrous episode, at the height of the statue-removing mania, in which some statues of classically-clad young women lifting aloft torches were removed from the entrance, out of fear that they depicted slave-girls. Later they were re-instated-- apparently someone had discovered that they weren't slave-girls after all.

But that's not the point of this post, nor is the military strengths or failures of the 1916 Rising. (Although I will say en passant that I've always thought such discussions are rather beside the point. There was no serious prospect of the 1916 Rising succeeding in military terms. It succeeded in rallying the country to fight the War of Independence. And if you don't think that succeeded, you're one of those utopian radicals who would never be satisfied with anything.)

No, the real point of this post is the sensations I felt on reading that sentence. I found myself thinking of Stephen's Green, where I've been innumerable times, and the Shelbourne Hotel, which I've passed innumerable times (and been in once). And I felt an intense delight in the fact that I can read printed words on a page and summon up these two places and the spatial relation between them.

I very often feel this sensation, and increasingly so. It seems to me very magical that two (or more) people can talk about a place where they've both been, and-- whoosh!-- they're there, or (even more magically) the place is conjured up around them, in a ghostly sort of way.

It's not that I get this sensation every time someone mentions a place, or even most of the time. It comes randomly.

When I started going to Mass (after emerging from my long agnostic phase), the parish priest in my local church would always say, during the announcement: "The Irish Catholic newspaper is on sale at the stand in the corner, along with various religious items." And I felt intense pleasure, and a sense of wonder, that everybody's minds (or eyes) could flash to that stand in the corner-- which was only a few steps away, but still somewhere else. And yet also in the same place, since we were surrounded by the same walls. Isn't that trippy? There are places within places, and places within those places...

Can We Fight Black Friday?

Once again-- as has been the custom in the last few years-- we are surrounded by ads for "Black Friday", that lamentable import from America.

Don't get me wrong. I love America. I love traditions. I don't even have a problem with commercialization, granted that the thing being commercialized isn't intrinsically bad.

Black Friday strikes me as intrinsically bad. Even Americans would do well to fight against it, I think. It's not commercializing anything-- it's pure consumerism and commercialization itself.

We're always told businesses respond to consumer demand. Would boycots and emails of complaint about this hideous new practice be of any use? Maybe they should be tried anyway.

Even if they called it "the Brian Boru sales", or something like that, I could get on board. But they don't.

Update: Feeling that I should follow my own advice, I sent a complaint to Harvey Norman (who sell furniture and electronic hardware), since it was one of their bus ads that prompted this train of thought. I can't reproduce my original complaint, since it was in an online form and I didn't get a copy. But it was pretty much the same as above-- right down to Brian Boru. This was their surprisingly prompt response:

Dear Maolsheachlann,

Thank you for taking the time to get in touch and share your thoughts.

I appreciate your point of view, and I understand that Black Friday is not traditionally an Irish event and that its increased use here in Ireland will not appeal to everyone.

While Black Friday has become a widely recognised retail event in Ireland in recent years, we do appreciate your feedback on how we promote our sales. I will make sure your comments are shared with the relevant team for consideration.

Thank you again for taking the time to contact us.

So there you go. Maybe if there were more such complaints it might make a difference. Businesses are unlikely to pass up any opportunity to make money, but they might at least rebrand it.

(A colleague suggested to me that shops and businesses just raise their prices on some things temporarily before Black Friday so they can safely say they've been reduced. I don't know if this is true.)

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Lists in Poetry

A very quick post about poetry. It's strange to me that some of my favourite lines in poetry are simply lists.

This came to mind today when I looked at the horizon and I thought of this wonderful line (italicized) from "Lines Written on Westminster Bridge" by William Wordsworth:

This City now doth, like a garment, wear
The beauty of the morning; silent, bare,
Ships, towers, domes, theatres, and temples lie
Open unto the fields, and to the sky;
All bright and glittering in the smokeless air.

Which reminded me of another line I love, from one of my favourite poetic passages ever, Prospero's speech in The Tempest. Admittedly this isn't a simple, descriptive list:

Our revels now are ended. These our actors, 
As I foretold you, were all spirits and 
Are melted into air, into thin air: 
And, like the baseless fabric of this vision, 
The cloud-capp'd towers, the gorgeous palaces, 
The solemn temples, the great globe itself, 
Yea, all which it inherit, shall dissolve 
And, like this insubstantial pageant faded, 
Leave not a rack behind. We are such stuff 
As dreams are made on, and our little life
Is rounded with a sleep.

And from there I go to possibly my favourite poem of all time, "Ulysses" by Lord Alfred Tennyson:

I am become a name;
For always roaming with a hungry heart
Much have I seen and known; cities of men
And manners, climates, councils, governments,
Myself not least, but honour'd of them all;
And drunk delight of battle with my peers,
Far on the ringing plains of windy Troy.

Then there's Paradise Lost:

Hear all ye Angels, Progenie of Light, 
Thrones, Dominations, Princedoms, Virtues, Powers, 
Hear my Decree, which unrevok't shall stand.

And this line from The Wanderings of Oisin by Yeats:

And there I will give you a hundred hounds;
No mightier creatures bay at the moon;
And a hundred robes of murmuring silk,
And a hundred calves and a hundred sheep
Whose long wool whiter than sea froth flows,
And a hundred spears and a hundred bows,
And oil and wine and honey and milk,
And always never-anxious sleep.

Do you agree, dear reader? Is there a special magic in lines of poetry that are simply lists of words? Do you have other examples?

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Make Ireland Erin Again

A question that occurs to me every now and again: when and why did Irish people stop calling Ireland "Erin"?

Old ballads and books are full of this poetic name for our country. I think we should start using it again.

People do sometimes say "the Emerald Isle", although rarely (I'm afraid) native Irish people. "The Land of Saints and Scholars" also-- often sarcastically. But Erin, hardly ever.

I hereby resolve that I will call Ireland Erin as often as I reasonably can.

Banba sometimes got a look in, although Fodla rarely. (Sisters of Erin in mythology-- or something like that.)

Also, why did people stop calling Ireland "Eire"? That's the official name of the country, and used to be used in English-language discourse around the middle of the century. This should also be brought back, especially when it seems that we're being asked to adopt some supposedly more accurate and native pronunciation of a foreign country or city every day.

What Are Some Good Resources on YouTube?

I frequently find myself looking for something to watch (or listen to) on YouTube while (for example) I'm eating-- if my eating requires two hands and I can't really read a book. There are lots of other situations that arise-- for instance, if I'm doing some task with my hands that doesn't require a great amount of attention.

Yes, silence, silence, SILENCE, I get it. Fine. I do incorporate silence (and device-free times) into my day, actually, so stop your yapping and sit down. 

YouTube is by far the most user-friendly video-sharing platform, in my experience, so that's why I use that one.

I'm really looking for something educational-- facts, and not opinion. I've spent far too long listening to partisan commentary. Of course, I like getting riled up and having my viewpoint buttressed by someone else as much as anyone else, and it's not like I'm going to stop seeking that out. 

On the other hand, anything I listen to would have to be at least non-woke, if not anti-woke. I've stopped listening to fairly good podcasts because any amount of woke is too much. Also, something relatively serious, not cute or jokey or zany.

What interests me the most is videos or podcasts that might teach me something about history, especially Christian history. I've listened to In Our Time and Great Lives (both BBC podcasts), but I'm not so keen on the format. I've listened to the free content on The Rest is HIstory, which is excellent. But they don't make (free) episodes quickly enough for me. What I'm looking for most of all is a dependable archive that can keep me going a good long while.

So-- any suggestions? I realize that's a pretty long list of requirements...