Thursday, November 19, 2026

A Strange Quirk, Perhaps

I've just been reading a book about the 1916 Rising leader, MIchael Mallin. (One of the lesser-known of the sixteen who were executed.) It includes this sentence: "The most infamous aspect of Mallin's Rising is the decision not to occupy, or attempt to occupy, the Shelbourne Hotel".

The Shelbourne Hotel is a large and historic hotel which overlooks Stephen's Green, the park in Dublin city centre in which Mallin's men set up their garrison. It's a luxury hotel that has hosted various famous people down the years, including John F. Kennedy. Recently there was a ludicrous episode, at the height of the statue-removing mania, in which some statues of classically-clad young women lifting aloft torches were removed from the entrance, out of fear that they depicted slave-girls. Later they were re-instated-- apparently someone had discovered that they weren't slave-girls after all.

But that's not the point of this post, nor is the military strengths or failures of the 1916 Rising. (Although I will say en passant that I've always thought such discussions are rather beside the point. There was no serious prospect of the 1916 Rising succeeding in military terms. It succeeded in rallying the country to fight the War of Independence. And if you don't think that succeeded, you're one of those utopian radicals who would never be satisfied with anything.)

No, the real point of this post is the sensations I felt on reading that sentence. I found myself thinking of Stephen's Green, where I've been innumerable times, and the Shelbourne Hotel, which I've passed innumerable times (and been in once). And I felt an intense delight in the fact that I can read printed words on a page and summon up these two places and the spatial relation between them.

I very often feel this sensation, and increasingly so. It seems to me very magical that two (or more) people can talk about a place where they've both been, and-- whoosh!-- they're there, or (even more magically) the place is conjured up around them, in a ghostly sort of way.

It's not that I get this sensation every time someone mentions a place, or even most of the time. It comes randomly.

When I started going to Mass (after emerging from my long agnostic phase), the parish priest in my local church would always say, during the announcement: "The Irish Catholic newspaper is on sale at the stand in the corner, along with various religious items." And I felt intense pleasure, and a sense of wonder, that everybody's minds (or eyes) could flash to that stand in the corner-- which was only a few steps away, but still somewhere else. And yet also in the same place, since we were surrounded by the same walls. Isn't that trippy? There are places within places, and places within those places...

No comments:

Post a Comment