"Flavour" is also relevant. Even though these four poets ranged far and wide in their exploration of life, their basic sensibility is one that appeals to me and in which I feel at home. Larkin's melancholy (and Englishness); MacNeice's relish for the passing moment, while constantly seeking for something more; Yeats's sense of the heroic; Tennyson's idealism constantly struggling with pessimism. And, on a more "granular" level (as we say these days), these are simply the four poets who, more than any others, consistently came up with phrases, lines, and turns of phrase that appeal to me. Without great craftsmanship, nobody (except modern poetry critics) would care about a poet's thoughts and ideas-- just like nobody would care about Paul McCartney's musings on heartbreak if he hadn't written the meoldy to "Yesterday".
"Lines on a Young Lady's Photograph Album" has had a huge influence on me personally, as a poet-- for whatever that's worth. I've written oodles of poems about a solitary, unnamed figure in a particular situation or setting, thinking about it. This is my favourite sort of poem to write. I've also written a few poems about photographs.
(What about Shakespeare? I don't really think of him as poet, though I agree this is quite arbitrary.)
Anyway, all that is a preamble that got away from me. The poem I wanted to feature today is "Lines on a Young Lady's Photograph Album" by Philip Larkin.
I consider this poem the foremost example of a whole sub-genre of poetry, what I might call "contemplating photographs" poetry. Photographs are endlessly evocative, and endlessly stimulating of the poetic mood.
But even beyond that distinct subgenre (which has its own unique virtues), I think this poem is an example of a broader subgenre of poetry-- poems about a particular person (usually unnamed) in a particular situation, contemplating it. The person is usually alone and little or nothing actually happens in the poem, other than the person's thoughts. This is the pattern of many of Larkin's poems, for instance "Church Going", "The Whitsun Weddings", "Aubade", "Sad Steps", and many others.
(I even invented a fake anthology of such poems, which I titled Thinking Alone: Poems of Solitary Reflection, and mock-announced in this blog post. To my surprise, a couple of commenters took it seriously. I'm never trying to fool people with such posts-- it's just a bit of fun, a bit of wishful thinking.)
"Lines on a Young Lady's Photograph Album" has had a huge influence on me personally, as a poet-- for whatever that's worth. I've written oodles of poems about a solitary, unnamed figure in a particular situation or setting, thinking about it. This is my favourite sort of poem to write. I've also written a few poems about photographs.
What I love about "Lines..." is its gentle melancholy and bittersweetness-- the sort of melancholy that is so gentle, it's really more pleasant than unpleasant.
Here are some of my favourite lines from it:
Too much confectionery, too rich:
I choke on such nutritious images.
And:
A sweet girl-graduate
And:
This is a real girl in a real place,
In every sense empirically true
And the fantastic, haunting last line:
Smaller and clearer as the years go by.
For all Larkin's well-advertised coarseness and crassness about sex, and about women, he could write brilliantly and touchingly about femininity, in all of its grace and gradations. (As I mentioned in a recent post, I really love the title of his novel A Girl in Winter-- partly for this reason.)
Fittingly for the theme, the poem itself seems like a period piece now. Does anybody keep photograph albums anymore? Does anyone get called a "young lady" these days?
Fittingly for the theme, the poem itself seems like a period piece now. Does anybody keep photograph albums anymore? Does anyone get called a "young lady" these days?
My favourite part of the poem is the meditation on photography:
But o, photography! as no art is,
Faithful and disappointing! that records
Dull days as dull, and hold-it smiles as frauds,
And will not censor blemishes
Like washing-lines, and Hall's-Distemper boards,
But shows a cat as disinclined, and shades
A chin as doubled when it is, what grace
Your candour thus confers upon her face!
How overwhelmingly persuades
That this is a real girl in a real place,
In every sense empirically true!
I could write endlessly about this poem, so I'll stop it there, and just give you the poem itself. (Is it ridiculous to have a lengthy discussion of a poem before presenting the text? Actually, I don't think so. I think it heightens the experience. I often read movie reviews before going to see a film.)
Lines On A Young Lady's Photograph Album
At last you yielded up the album, which
Once open, sent me distracted. All your ages
Matt and glossy on the thick black pages!
Too much confectionery, too rich:
I choke on such nutritious images.
My swivel eye hungers from pose to pose —
In pigtails, clutching a reluctant cat;
Or furred yourself, a sweet girl-graduate;
Or lifting a heavy-headed rose
Beneath a trellis, or in a trilby-hat
(Faintly disturbing, that, in several ways) —
From every side you strike at my control,
Not least through those these disquieting chaps who loll
At ease about your earlier days:
Not quite your class, I'd say, dear, on the whole.
But o, photography! as no art is,
Faithful and disappointing! that records
Dull days as dull, and hold-it smiles as frauds,
And will not censor blemishes
Like washing-lines, and Hall's-Distemper boards,
But shows a cat as disinclined, and shades
A chin as doubled when it is, what grace
Your candour thus confers upon her face!
How overwhelmingly persuades
That this is a real girl in a real place,
In every sense empirically true!
Or is it just the past? Those flowers, that gate,
These misty parks and motors, lacerate
Simply by being you; you
Contract my heart by looking out of date.
Yes, true; but in the end, surely, we cry
Not only at exclusion, but because
It leaves us free to cry. We know what was
Won't call on us to justify
Our grief, however hard we yowl across
The gap from eye to page. So I am left
To mourn (without a chance of consequence)
You, balanced on a bike against a fence;
To wonder if you'd spot the theft
Of this one of you bathing; to condense,
In short, a past that no one now can share,
No matter whose your future; calm and dry,
It holds you like a heaven, and you lie
Unvariably lovely there,
Smaller and clearer as the years go by.

No comments:
Post a Comment