I've finally got round to reading The Vritue of Nationalism by Yoram Hazony, a book which I've known about for a long time but which I somehow haven't actually read, despite having easy access to it.
Everybody has subjects on which they find it almost impossible to be fair-minded, and I'll admit that nationalism is one for me. I don't like anti-nationalists. The fact that someone has a visceral dislike of nationalism gives me a visceral dislike of them. This might be overcome given other circumstances, but the point is-- that person is immediately off to a bad start with me. Is this fair? No, but there it is.
One example of this is when I bought the Simply Red album Home (yes, I like Simply Red's music, what of it). The last song was titled "Little Englander" and faded out on the charming refrain: "Let me smash the plastic face of my country". As soon as I heard this, I gave the album away to a charity shop. (This was towards the end of the CD era.)
Having said that, I don't think nationalism is product of the viscera. I think it makes perfect sense, especially in our modern world, especially given current developments. I'm only a few chapters in, but Hazony makes the case very eloquently.
Incidentally, I like the fact that this book was written by a Jewish writer. There's an antisemitic trope that's popular on the right, or at least, on the online right, which clalims that Jewish people are pro-globalism except when it comes to Israel. I can think of plenty of counter-examples, but this author has written a whole book supporting nationalism in general.
One thing I learned from this book is that Edmund Burke described John Locke's Second Treatise of Government-- which Hazony identifies as the fount of all post-nationalist ideas-- as one of the worst books ever written, while talking in Parliament!
I really like this passage, in which Hazony is describing how the Lockean post-nationalist paradigm has become unquestioned orthodoxy among "educated" people: "Having been initiated into this liberal paradigm, educated men and women can now find employment within a vast array of projects that assume a liberal construction of the world is coming; the political program of European unification; the expansion of unfettered free trade and the free immigration of populations; the transitioning of business enterprises into "multinational" corporations that serve the global economy rather than any particular national interest; the subjugation of nations to an ever-expanding body of international law; the agitation for a universal regime of human rights through non-governmental organizations, UN bodies, and international courts; the homogenization of the world's universities by way of a system of international standards and peer review. All these things are pursued as a matter of course by university-trained Lockeans, hardly aware that there might be intelligent and decent pesons whose esitmation of the worth of such enterprises can either be "on the right side of history" or "on the wrong side of history", and that when you are working at building up the new liberal order, you are on the right side."
I work in a university library. I can remember the theatrical scenes of mourning and desolation the day after the Brexit vote. People were comforting each other as though they had all suffered a collective bereavement. The notion that anyone might be cheering Brexit was unthinkable, apparently. It's regularly assumed that everyone working in a university must be in favour of all the projects Hazony lists.)
I also like this passage, which I haven't actually reached yet but which I came across as I was flicking through the book: "Neo-Catholics will continue to fight rearguard culture wars against liberal elites on issues such as abortion or the definition of marriage. But at the same time, they will be found offering active or passive support to the liberal imperialism that is uprooting the ability of nations to maintain their independence on constitutional and religious matters of precisely this kind."
I don't know what the writer means by "neo-Catholics", as I haven't come to the part where he introduces that definition. But I have certainly met Catholics like this, who are totally committed to the project of European unification, in the face of clear evidence that the European Union has a strident socially liberal (and anti-life) agenda. Indeed, even great intellects such as John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI seem to have a weirdly naive view of the EU and other globalist institutions. This is one subject on which I cannot agree with the noises that have been coming from Rome for many decades now. (Pro-Europe Catholics often point out the project was initatied by Christian Democrats, including the candidate for sainthood Robert Schuman, and that the EU flag-- which I think is a very attractive flag-- is inspired by the Virgin Mary's crown of stars. Well, that's all as may be, but it's taken a very different turn in our time.)

No comments:
Post a Comment